Single Post Template: Parent: Blog Posts

Essence: What a Tint

The Internet has spoken, and we must agree this is the best Benetint Lip Tint dupe of all time. Not only does it come at a fraction of the price, but it delivers the same pigment as the original product.

What a Tint has a similar consistency that applies the same way in a dot and blend fashion to create a natural, rosy flush. While Benetint has a classic rose fragrance, Essence has a fruiter scent. It’s absorbent, smudge-proof, kiss-proof, and long-lasting, and the color, swipe, and feel are spot on.


  • Versatile for lips and cheeks

  • Resists smudging and lasts all-day

  • Spot-on consistency for easy blending

  • Perfect color dupe for Benetint

  • Vegan, cruelty-free, and free of parabens and oil


  • Scent differs from Benetint's rose fragrance

Etude House Water Tint

With a lovely, natural flush, Etude House in Strawberry shade also rivals Benetint. It offers a glossier look that’s absorbent and kiss-proof. Packed with vitamins and berry complexes, this lip stain has a lightweight, non-sticky finish.


  • Delivers a fresh, natural tint

  • Hydrating ingredients for lip care

  • Lightweight with a non-sticky feel

  • Stay-put smudge-proof formula


  • May not be super water-resistant

Weightless Water Lip Stain

This water-based formula delivers a slightly more pigmented look than Benetint, which makes it buildable or easy to sheer out for a weightless and natural look. The clean formula has a sweet cherry scent and is packed with green tea extract to smooth skin texture, aloevera, and hyaluronic acid to hydrate your lips, and glycerin, a natural humectant, to help the lip stain glide on sleek and smooth with long-lasting staying power.


  • Water-based formula

  • Infused with skin-loving natural ingredients

  • Buildable and Long-wearing

  • Sheer, natural finish

  • Aloe vera and hyaluronic acid hydrate

  • Clean formula with positive feedback


  • May require reapplication for intensity

TonyMoly Delight Tony Tint in Cherry Pink

Do you want a sheer, matte, high-impact finish that stays put all day? Check out this Benetint alternative. The formula is more pigmented, so you can build it or swipe it for a more sheer, natural look.


  • Delivers a sheer to bold matte look

  • Flexible buildable intensity


  • Can be a little messy

Maybelline Super-Stay Vinyl Ink Lip Color in Deep Wine

Get luscious lips with this dupe that delivers a swipe of vibrant, deep-red wine color. The brand’s vegan Color Lock formula ensures that your lip color stays in place up to 16 hours. Aloevera and Vitamin E help keep your lips smooth and hydrated.


  • Durable wear for up to 16 hours

  • Vegan-friendly ingredients


  • May feel sticky

NYX Duck Plumping Up Gloss in Hall of Flame

You can always count on the NYX brand for quality and affordable dupes for more expensive viral trends. This plumping gloss will give you extreme duck lips without Botox, thanks to the spicy ginger formula infused with fruit extracts.


  • Visibly enhances lip fullness

  • Moisturizing benefits from fruit extracts

  • Similar tint


  • Can cause a temporary tingling sensation in the lips

Ultralip in Cranberry

Glossier offers an understated, luxe look that you can wear every day. This one-step lipstick is buttery, buildable, and packed with nourishing jojoba seed oil, meadowfoam, and watermelon seed oil that locks in hydration.


  • Buildable formula

  • Ethically Vegan and cruelty-free

  • Conditioning and hydrating

  • Gentle and fragrance-free


  • Price

Choosing the Best Benetint Lip Tint Alternative

Benetint Lip Tint has been a symbol of style and power for decades. Its water-based formula has a natural sheen that looks good on diverse skin types.

The original Benetint formula contained steamed rose petals, while the modern formula is packed with carmine to ensure an enviable scarlet sheen.

Whether you’re looking for a similar product that’s a little more natural or affordable or want to try other options, we’ve got you covered.

These Benetint dupes have been chosen for their similarity to the original product, in many cases, from tint and hydration to packaging and ingredients, so you’re sure to find a new favorite on the list.

The Most Affordable Benetint Lip Tint Alternative

Essence What a Tint wins our vote, hands down, for its spot-on color, natural finish, and crazy affordable price.

Our Favorite Benetint Lip Tint Dupe

We love how Ulta’s Weightless Lip Stain delivers a sheer or buildable natural finish that mimics Benetint’s long-lasting color. It's super affordable and infused with natural ingredients to help your lips stay fresh and hydrated all day.